The Real Reason Renting a Car in Cancun Is Both a Good and Bad Idea

If you’re planning a trip to Cancun and wondering, “Should I rent a car?”—the answer isn’t as simple as you might think.

We rented a car in Cancun, and honestly? It was a bit of a rollercoaster. There were moments it felt stressful, confusing, and not at all what we expected… but at the same time, having a car gave us a level of freedom we wouldn’t trade.

That’s why this isn’t a typical “yes or no” guide.

I’m breaking down the real pros and cons of renting a car in Cancun, what caught us off guard, how driving compares to the U.S., and the situations where having a car actually makes your trip better.

By the end, you’ll know exactly whether renting a car in Cancun is the right move for your trip—and how to avoid the mistakes most travelers make. 

This post may contain affiliate links (including Amazon Affiliate links) that will give a commission at no additional charge to you.

How to Rent a Car in Mexico

There are a few ways to rent a car in Cancun Mexico.  You can book online ahead of time or while you are on vacation.

Book Online for Renting a Car in Cancun

I always like to book my rental cars ahead of time.  It usually saves money the earlier you book.  I usually use Priceline. 

I have had a lot of luck using Priceline because they offer a free cancelation policy.  I also like to compare prices with the different companies.  Normally, I only book with well-known companies.

Renting a Car in Cancun at the Airport

As you enter the airport there will be lots of salespeople wanting to set you up with a car rental. 

Here is a Cancun car rental tip – avoid these interactions.  It is hard to know if they are legit or if they just want money to help you get to the right spot. 

Renting a Car at Your Hotel

Another option for renting a car in Cancun Mexico is once you get to your hotel.  Your concierge can provide a car rental company or shuttle transportation for you. No worries! 

Should I Rent a Car in Cancun?

Should you rent a car in Cancun? Okay, I am not going to beat around the bush.  No.  Well, probably not, as in a qualified no.  

As we planned our 7-day Cancun itinerary, we really wanted to rent a car so that we could have the freedom to explore the Yucatan Peninsula and go on a few Cancun day trips to Chichen Itza, Xcaret, Cozumel, Costa Maya, Merida, Isla Mujeres, and the city of Izamal. 

Renting a Car in Cancun From a “National Brand”

We rented from a national brand we are used to in the US. We expected more and because of our experience, we would not do it again.  

In the image above, you can see how many parts of the car were damaged when we received the car. 

Do I Need a Car in Cancun?

You really have to ask yourself if you need a car in Cancun to know if it is worth it. Going on a tour to Chichen Itza or a tour to Xcaret is not much more than the total cost of renting a car in Cancun. (especially if you are on a couples trip)

Benefits of Renting a Car in Cancun

You probably know all the benefits of having a Cancun rental car:

No Waiting

One major benefit of renting a car in Cancun is that you can create your own schedule and go at your own pace.

No waiting for a bus; no waking up early for a scheduled departure; your car is waiting for you whenever you want it.  Freedom to choose when and where you want to go. 

Comfort

A car should be more comfortable than a taxi, bus, or other means of public transportation.  You won’t rip yourself off.  You hopefully like the people that are in the car with you.  And you will have more space.  

Choose Your Destination

You can call the shots.  If you see a shop at the side of the highway you want to check out you have the freedom to do so.   

It is difficult if you are trying to communicate with your bus driver “para.”  If the driver does stop, it will be to drop you off.  You will be waving down another bus, hoping it will stop to pick you up.    

Taxis can help, but it’s going to cost you more if you add a stop and they need to wait.  Besides, in a car, you can take detours kilometers off the beaten path.  

These are just some of the reasons why we usually rent cars when we travel.  We like the ability to explore and the freedom to go when we want.  These were just some of the reasons we wanted to rent a car in Mexico Cancun area. 

Why is Renting a Car in Cancun Different?

Renting a car in Cancun, whether it be by the Cancun airport or elsewhere, is a whole different ball game from your U.S. rental car experience.

  I am going to give you a few examples and experiences of the car rental service that we had so that you can be prepared for your Cancun rental car.

So What Makes Renting a Car in Cancun, Mexico So Different?

• Extra Cost
• Quality
• Language Barrier
• Lack of GPS signal

Let’s explore each of these Cancun rental car tips and topics in more detail.

1. Cost of a Rental Car in Cancun

Renting a Car in Cancun at the Airport 

It’s going to cost you more than you think.  Yes, you may see a jaw-dropping deal online from a reputable company, but that’s before full coverage insurance and the fine print. 

Additional Insurance Mexico Car Rental

Nope, you can’t skip it gringo.  As a foreign national, your credit card insurance and U.S. insurance means nothing.  You are going to have to pay up to get your auto.  So be prepared to pay up. 

How Much is the Extra Cancun Car Rental Insurance?

It is an insane amount of money for Cancun rental car insurance.  Over $200 and that was the bare minimum.  We purchased third-party liability insurance through Priceline which was an extra $13 dollars a day.  It meant nothing. 

The car rental company would not accept it fully.  They did say we didn’t have to pay a certain portion of their insurance but for the most part, it was worthless.

They also made us sign a collision damage waiver form that said we were in a wreck and were responsible for the damages.   We thought that was corrupt since we clearly hadn’t driven the car yet.  They said they disregard the form when you return the car in the same condition as you received it. 

This was the start of our Cancun rental car experience.

Renting a Car in Cancun at Your Hotel

Here is a Cancun Car rental tip. If you rent a car in Cancun specifically at your hotel it may be a different experience. I can’t be 100% sure because we did not use this method but you might avoid the insurance issue by renting from your hotel.  Let us know your experience in the comments. 

2. Quality of the Rental Car in Cancun

As we walked out to our car we were shocked.  The cars were old and beat up.  I mean half of them looked like they had been in serious wrecks.

One thing to consider before renting a car in Cancun is that the car may break down on you.  I understand that when I choose an economy car and I am not upgraded, I get a pretty basic car in the U.S.  But it has always been relatively new with low miles.  That wasn’t my experience in Mexico. Here is my renting a car in Cancun advice and experience.

Renting a Car in Cancun with High Miles

Our Cancun rental car was a Volkswagen compact car that had something like 70,000 miles (it had 115,000 kilometers or so), but it looked like it had 200,000 miles. 

It was pretty beat up, and when we drove it on the tollway to and from Chichen Itza, one of the wheels sounded like it was going to fall off at any minute.  

Air Conditioning

I know as an American, I am spoiled.  Believe me, I lived in Germany and was shocked when I realized that my apartment did not have air-condition.  

Germany doesn’t get too hot, but Cancun is in the Caribbean.  It is hot!   Our car blew air that maybe was somewhat cooler than the outside air but not much.  We had a long road trip without a decent air-conditioner.  I am not going to lie, it was tough. 

This definitely made me ask the question, “Should I ever rent a car in Cancun again?”

3. Cancun Rental Car Tips – Be Alert at the Gas Stations

If you do decide to rent a car in Mexico filling it up with gas is stressful.  There are attendants at every pump that fill the car up for you.  These attendants typically only speak Spanish.

Don’t Get Robbed! Is it Safe to Drive in Cancun?

You could get robbed when you try to get gas.  You won’t get jumped, but at one place they took our credit card and very quickly skimmed it.  Within about 30 seconds of them having my card, I got a text from Chase Bank alerting me of possible fraud for over $400 (U.S. dollars, not pesos hombre). Never use a debit card! 

On top of that, we are pretty sure they charged us separately way too much for gas (about $35 U.S. dollars for maybe half a tank). 

We had read about one of these tactics, but others have blogged and indicated it wasn’t a problem. The hotel staff had told us not to worry. 

Well, we had to learn one of life’s lessons on our own.  Let’s just say we learned the best way is to pay with pesos. From then on we carefully watched the pump to make sure the number started at zero and went up to what we asked for. 

4. GPS Failure

Just a heads up… You may get lost when driving in Cancun Mexico.  Google Maps failed us.  First off, your international roaming plan may make Google Maps expensive to use.  We didn’t use it much, but when we did, it did not work so great. 

Connectivity Issues

When leaving Chichen Itza, we decided to go back to Cancun’s hotel zone using the older (non-toll) highway and to also visit Valladolid.

When going straight out of Chichen Itza and about the point you turn right to get to the tollway, I think you need to turn left to go the way we wanted.  Google Maps lost connection and we kept going straight. 

We figured we were going west and not east based on the signs to Merida and Izamal and the direction of the sun, but thought at first maybe the road needed to curve.  Nope.  We decided to just keep going and visit Izamal. 

It was fine but made for a long day, and a late night of eating room service at 12:30 a.m., trying to fill our bellies before collapsing for the night.

GPS Fail

It wasn’t just a connectivity issue.  Google Maps was supposed to take us to the ferry close to Playa Del Carman that takes cars to Cozumel. 

Google took us to a residential area.  This isn’t all Google’s fault, as addresses are hard to find for some places, but the fact remains that for whatever the reason, it’s a bit hard to navigate by GPS. Driving in Cancun and in the Yucatan can be tricky! 

5. Cancun Rental Car Tips – Language Barrier

I have a few Cancun rental car tips that I wanted to share. The road signs are in Spanish.  Okay, so you’re on the same side of the road as the US.  And yes, you will understand city names and other names. 

But you will need to be careful of the topas (speed bumps).  Look for the yellow signs.  But if you drive to Cancun itself or other places, those speed bumps may sneak up on you. 

Also, watch out to your left or right.  You may think there is only one lane, but there may very well be more.  Driving in Cancun can be tricky but hopefully, these Cancun car rental tips will help you. 

Driving in Cancun and the Yucatan Area

I actually thought the roads in Cancun were pretty good. It made driving in Cancun easy.  Some areas do have faded lines.  And this is not just off the beaten path.  

We noticed this on the main highway between Cancun and Playa del Carmen.  But overall, they were not that bad. 

Toll Roads

If you want to go from Cancun to Chichen Itza the recommended way to go is on the Toll-Way.  Be prepared because it is an expensive road to drive on. $30 in tolls each way! This does add to your cost of renting a car in Cancun.

It appears that they try hard to update and keep the road nice.  I did not think driving in Cancun was a bad experience. The speed limits were nice, it was 110km which is about 68 mph. 

Frequently Asked Questions About Renting a Car in Cancun

If you were looking for Cancun car rental reviews I hope my experience helped you out. You might have a few more questions about the whole renting a car in Mexico process. I am going to answer a few basic questions.

Can You Rent a Car in Mexico?

Yes, you can rent a car. There are major rental car companies like Budget and Hertz in Cancun.  

Is it Safe to Rent a Car in Mexico Cancun?

I felt safe in all the tourist areas we traveled to. Was my car safe? I wasn’t sure if we were going to lose a wheel That is a different story.

Can you Rent a Car in Mexico with a US Drivers Licence?

Yes, you can use a US driver’s license to rent a car in Mexico.  You do not need to have an international driving permit or license. 

Does My Credit Card Cover Car Rental Insurance in Mexico?

No, major car companies will not accept it and will make you pay for the personal liability insurance offered through the company.  

What Insurance Do You Need When Renting a Car in Mexico?

Unfortunately, you will have to pay a lot of money to the Car rental company as they do not accept third-party insurance policies like Priceline or Credit Card policies. 

Can I Rent a Car in Mexico at 18?

Yes, at some car rental companies, you can rent a car at the minimum age of 18 with a valid driver’s licence. Those between the ages of 18-25 will be charged an additional 10 USD a day. 

Where to Rent a Car in Mexico

The Cancun International Airport is where you will find many car rental companies.  If you decide to rent a car I would book ahead of time.  You can also rent a car from some hotels. 

Should You Rent A Car In Cancun?

I love freedom so I typically always lean towards renting a car.  Cancun was a different experience that has me questioning if I would ever do that again. 

I would say I would not rent a car in Cancun from the airport.  Next time I will try and have the hotel arrange something for me and maybe it will turn out better.  

Being the planner that I am it is hard to wait until the last minute.  I love booking things ahead of time.  As you plan and pack for Cancun, hopefully, this helps you know if you should rent a car in Cancun. 

Leave a comment, let me know your thoughts and experiences and Cancun tips, and if you think someone should rent a car in Cancun.

Facebook Group

If you have any questions when planning your trip come join me in my private Facebook Group.  This group is a place where you can ask any question about your upcoming trip and help others plan their trips.  It is also a place where I put travel deals.

Need Help with Converting Kilometers to Miles? Use this calculator below!